Cardboard Tigers: Didier, Face, and Farmer

Fourth in an occasional series. Collect ’em all!

I’m working through a stack of Tigers baseball cards from the late 1960s and early 1970s. I also have most of the 1968 World Champion team’s cards, but I’m going to feature them separately. So this series is mostly lesser-known players from that period.

Bob Didier
Bob Didier 1974 Topps #482

Bob Didier was a backup catcher for the Tigers in 1973. He made it to the major leagues in 1969 with Atlanta, where he hit .256 in 352 at bats with 16 doubles and 32 RBI. He finished fourth in the N.L. Rookie of the Year voting and started every game in the Braves’ NLCS appearance against the Mets.

Unfortunately, it was downhill from there. Arm and back problems limited him to only 133 more games over the next five seasons, four in Atlanta, one in Detroit, and a brief stop in Boston in 1975.

Bob was a good defensive catcher, leading the International League with a .997 fielding percentage in 1972 according to the back of this card, which also notes that he was a quarterback in high school. When they feel the need to mention stuff like that, it’s generally not a good sign.

Bob went on to manage and coach in the major and minor leagues for the Tigers, White Sox, Dodgers, Cubs, Athletics, and Mariners, and also worked for the Diamondbacks as their catching coordinator.

What I remember most about Bob is that his last name was pronounced more or less with the French pronunciation, “Dee-dee-ay,” and he was a switch-hitter, which was unusual for a catcher, both of which made him seem far more sophisticated than he likely was.

Bob also taught catching techniques for Big League Experience camps. Here’s a video from 2011:

Roy Face was one of the first closers in baseball history. In an era when starters were often expected to pitch late into a game or even throw a complete game, the bullpen roles were usually spread among the relievers. There weren’t the specialty roles we see today: left-handed specialist, long reliever, setup man, closer. Roy became the template for the modern closer, though his appearances were often two or even three innings of work. He was the first reliever to save 20 or more games in a season twice, held the record for career saves (193) until 1982, and still holds the record for most wins as a relief pitcher (96).

Roy Face
Roy Face 1969 Topps #207

He pitched for the Pirates from 1953 to 1968, pitching in 802 games over 15 seasons with an ERA of 3.33. He was a National League All-Star six times (he played in the two All-Star Games played each year from 1959 to 1961), and finished seventh in the N.L. Most Valuable Player voting in 1959, which was unheard of for a relief pitcher.

Roy was very briefly a member of the Tigers’ 1968 squad; he was sold by Pirates to Detroit on August 31, but only made two appearances for the eventual World Series champions for a total of one inning. He wasn’t on the roster for the World Series. This is his 1969 card, printed before he’d signed with the Expos, and for which Topps didn’t even bother to try to airbrush out his Pirates uniform. He doesn’t look all that happy about the whole thing, really.

In 1969, he signed as a free agent with the expansion Montreal Expos where he finished his career at the age of 41, appearing in 44 games and saving five of them with an ERA of 4.53.

Roy started only 27 of the 848 games he pitched, and 23 of those were in his first two seasons in Pittsburgh. In the offseason, he worked as a carpenter and after his retirement from baseball he did that full-time, working as the carpentry foreman at Mayview State Hospital outside of Pittsburgh. Roy’s still around at the age of 92, last living in his adopted home of Allegheny County, Pennsylvania.

Ed Farmer
Ed Farmer 1974 Topps #506

Ed Farmer was a Chicago legend. He was a hot high school pitching prospect while at St. Rita of Cascia High School on the south side in the mid-sixties. Drafted by the Indians in 1967, he worked his way through the Cleveland farm system, making 105 mostly relief (and mostly unimpressive) appearances for the big club from 1971 to 1973. Traded to Detroit in June of 1973 for Tom Timmerman and minor leaguer Kevin Collins, he pitched in 24 games for the Tigers, all in relief, going 3-0 with a 5.00 ERA.

After suffering an arm injury, Farmer re-invented his delivery and found much more success. His best years were with his hometown White Sox from 1979-81, where he served as closer and put up 54 of his lifetime total of 75 saves. He was an American League All-Star in 1980. Ed also played for the Phillies (twice), Orioles, Brewers, Rangers, and A’s.

When his pitching career ended, Ed worked as a scout for the Orioles, and then in the front office for the White Sox. In 1991 he began his radio career for the White Sox, eventually becoming the play-by-play announcer in 2006. He was beginning his 30th season behind the microphone for the Sox when kidney disease sidelined him during spring training in Feburary 2020. He died on April 1, 2020, at the age of 70.

The White Sox wore sleeve patches with his nickname, “Farmio,” throughout the shortened 2020 season.

Sleeve patch with "Farmio" wording
Ed Farmer memorial patch worn by the White Sox in 2020

Cardboard Tigers: Ike Brown, Bruton, Colbert, and Coleman

Third in an occasional series. Collect ’em all!

Ike Brown
Ike Brown 1972 Topps #284

Ike Brown was a utility infielder and outfielder for the Tigers in the early seventies. He was the kind of player who wouldn’t embarrass you wherever you put him, hit well enough that you could consider using him as an occasional pinch hitter (though with Gates Brown – no relation – also on the team, those opportunities didn’t happen often), and always seemed like a nice teammate. He wore the stylish wireframe glasses you see on both his 1972 and 1974 cards before they became commonplace, not to mention that few ballplayers wore glasses during games at all, and along with his linebacker build, he was a recognizable and popular Tiger each of his seasons with the club.

Ike came up about the time the Tigers put last names on the back of their uniforms, and he wore “I. BROWN” while Gates wore “G. BROWN,” which I somehow thought was pretty sophisticated. Now we have a plethora of SRs, JRs, IIIs, and IVs it feels a little out of control, but Ike and Gates were trendsetters in the uni nameplate world.

Ike Brown
Ike Brown 1974 Topps #409

Other than being the Don Kelly or Andrew Romine of his day in Detroit, Ike has two other interesting distinctions:

  • He hit a home run in his first major league at bat on June 17, 1969 at Yankee Stadium. Considering he only hit 19 more in 536 total big league at bats, the trend was definitely downhill from there.
  • Ike was the last player who had played in the Negro Leagues to debut in the majors. The Tigers signed him from the Kansas City Monarchs in 1961.

Ike died in 2001 in his hometown of Memphis, Tennessee, at the age of 59.

Bill Bruton
Bill Bruton 1963 Topps #437

Bill Bruton was a very fast outfielder for the Milwaukee Braves (1953-1960) and the Tigers (1961-64). A good hitter and an above-average fielder with good range due to his speed, he led the National League in stolen bases for three consecutive years from his rookie season of 1953 through 1955, racking up totals of 26, 34, and 25 swipes, which should give you an idea how often NL teams were running in the early fifties. Bill played for the Milwaukee Brewers of the American Association in 1952 when the team was the top farm club for the Boston Braves. The next year he was promoted to the bigs but didn’t have to move as the Braves moved to Milwaukee. When fans think of western expansion of the major leagues they usually think of the Dodgers and Giants moving to California in 1958, but the Braves were the first to head west, though they only went as far as Wisconsin. Bill had the game-winning home run in the bottom of the 10th inning in the transplanted Milwaukee Braves’ first game on April 14, 1953, as they beat the St. Louis Cardinals, 3-2.

Bill hit two bases loaded triples in the same game in 1959, something that had only been done once before (Elmer Valo in 1949) and once since (Duane Kuiper in 1978). That may not seem like much of a record to share, but it probably got Bill a beer or two.

Bill died in a car crash that was caused by an apparent heart attack outside of Wilmington, Delaware, in 1995. He was 70 years old.

Nate Colbert
Nate Colbert 1975 Topps #599

Nate Colbert was a power hitter. He hit 173 home runs in his ten-year major league career with the Astros, Padres, Tigers, Expos, and A’s. Mostly remembered for his years in San Diego, he was a National League All-Star three times from 1971 to 1973, years in which he hit 27, 38, and 22 home runs and racked up 84, 111, and 80 RBI. Plagued with back problems, he was traded to Detroit after a down 1974 season in the three-team deal involving Eddie Brinkman that I mentioned the other day. Nate only played 45 games for the Tigers before being sold to Montreal in June. He played 52 games for the Expos in 1975 and 1976 before they also let him go. He spent the rest of the bicentennial year in the minors before making one last brief appearance with Oakland at the end of the season, going 0 for 6 with one walk in two games. He retired at the age of 30.

I love Nate’s smile in this 1975 Topps card. This is a classic baseball card photographer’s trick: get at least one shot from underneath the ball cap, so if the player is traded you won’t have to airbrush the new team’s colors and logo onto the crown of the hat. This explains Nate’s snappy jersey piping in the photo, which appears to have been done with a chisel-tip Sharpie marker, but does not at all explain why the upper deck of Jack Murphy Stadium is visible behind him.

Nate had the bad luck to play with nine last-place teams in a row from 1968 to 1976. He had a brief cup of coffee with the Astros in 1966 (they finished eighth in the then-ten-team National League) and, as mentioned above, finished with the A’s in 1976 (they finished second in the AL West that year). In 1975, he played with two last-place teams: the Tigers and the Expos.

He deserved better, yet somehow he was able to keep smiling. Unlike many of the players we’ve met so far in this series, Nate is still alive at the age of 74.

Joe Coleman
Joe Coleman 1974 Topps #240

Joe Coleman was always one of the American League’s leaders in the “Largest Lump of Chaw” competition. And he only got better with age. I mean, look at the 1974 card: only a small bump showing through his left cheek. By the next year, though, as seen below, Joe really was getting good, with a wad of chewing tobacco so big he couldn’t even close his mouth anymore. By 1976, the chaw was threatening to take over his face and maybe petition to get its own zip code, and he appears to have been drooling tobacco onto his left knee as well.

I don’t understand the poses on Joe’s cards. He seems to be getting ready to pitch or has just delivered a killer curveball despite appearing to be standing nowhere near a pitcher’s mound but instead somewhere along the first base stands. That is not how you play baseball, Joe. At least he has his glove in position, ready to spear a hot liner through the box.

Joe Coleman
Joe Coleman 1975 Topps #42

Joe’s father was also a major league pitcher for ten seasons from 1942 to 1955, interrupted for three years by World War Two. He played mostly for the Philadelphia Athletics before finishing two short stints with Baltimore (as shown in this special 1976 card with son Joe, Jr.) and finally with the Tigers, where he went 2-1 with a 3.20 ERA and three saves in 17 games at the end of the 1955 season. If you look closely, Joe Sr. seems to have a wad of chewing tobacco in his left cheek as well, right down to the crooked grimace. Pass the tradition along, Joe! (Incidentally, Joe Jr.’s son Casey pitched for the Cubs in 2010-12 and briefly for the Royals in 2014, making the Colemans one of the few three-generation big league families.)

Joe Coleman and Joe Coleman, Jr.
“Father and Son – Big Leaguers” Joe Coleman and Joe Coleman, Jr. – 1976 Topps #68
Joe Coleman
Joe Coleman 1976 Topps #456

Joe was a very good starting pitcher for the Senators (1965-70) and the Tigers (1971-76), and then a succession of other teams over the next four seasons before hanging ’em up. With the Tigers in 1972, he was part of an excellent starting rotation that led the team, which wasn’t exactly an offensive juggernaut, to the American League East division championship. The staff was led by Mickey Lolich (22-14, 2.50 ERA, 250 Ks), Coleman (19-14, 2.80 ERA, 222 Ks), and August pickup Woodie Fryman (10-3, 2.06 ERA, 72 Ks), plus a solid bullpen of Chuck Seelbach (14 saves, 2.89 ERA), Fred Scherman (12 saves, 3.64 ERA), and John Hiller (3 saves, 2.03 ERA)

The Tigers lost to Oakland in the 1972 ALCS, 3 games to 2, with the most memorable moment coming in the seventh inning of Game 2, when Tiger reliever Lerrin LaGrow hit A’s shortstop Bert Campaneris in the foot with a pitch, causing Campy to hurl his bat at LaGrow, who was wise enough to duck as the bat sailed by. The benches cleared, Billy Martin had to be restrained by several Tigers and the umpiring crew to keep him from fighting Campaneris. Here’s a clip of the incident, with George Kell and Larry Osterman of WWJ-TV (Channel 4) with the call:

Joe was later a pitching coach and minor league manager, finishing his over 50 year career in baseball with the Jupiter Hammerheads of the Florida State League. He’s retired now at the age of 74, and reportedly spends his time in Florida and Tennessee.

Cardboard Tigers: Arroyo, Bare, and Brinkman

Second in an ongoing series.

Two fairly obscure Tigers today plus “Steady Eddie.”

Detroit Tigers pitcher Fernando Arroyo
Fernando Arroyo 1976 Topps #614

This is Fernando Arroyo, sporting the Tigers’ old double-knit pullover road jerseys. Fernando looks very serious in this photo. He was a 6’2″ right-handed starter who was drafted by the Tigers in the eleventh round in 1970, then spent the next six seasons working his way through the farm system, including stops in Bristol, Lakeland, Montgomery, and Evansville. In 1975, he finally made it to the bigs, throwing 53 innings as a middle reliever and spot starter, going 2-1 with an ERA of 4.58.

Despite getting a shiny 1976 Topps card with his 24-year-old face on it, he didn’t pitch in the majors that year, but did spend parts of the next three seasons in Detroit before finishing his career with the Twins (1980-82) and the A’s (1982 and briefly in 1986). His career totals included a 24-37 record in 121 games, 60 of them starts, and a 4.44 ERA.

Fernando is a member of the Mexican-American Hall of Fame in his hometown of Sacramento, California.

Detroit Tigers pitcher Ray Bare
Ray Bare 1976 Topps #507

Ray Bare was another right-handed pitcher for the Tigers from 1975-77. Drafted by the Cardinals in the supplemental draft in 1969, the Tigers bought him before spring training in 1975. He went 8-13 that season, mostly as a starter, with a 4.48 ERA. The back of this card notes that he threw a two-hit shutout against the California Angels on August 16, which broke a 19-game losing streak for the Tigers. Probably the highlight of a short major league career, which ended two years later. After starting the 1977 season with a 12.56 ERA, the Tigers sent Ray down to Evansville, then released him after the season. The Orioles gave him one more shot in 1978 with their AAA farm team, the Rochester Red Wings, but that was the end of the road for Ray.

Most players usually looked a bit different from year to year on their baseball cards, but Ray always had this expression and this mustache. Ray Bare died of leukemia in 1994 at the age of 44 in his hometown of Miami, Florida.

Detroit Tigers shortstop Ed Brinkman
Ed Brinkman 1974 Topps #138
Detroit Tigers shortstop Ed Brinkman
Ed Brinkman 1975 Topps #439

Ah, Steady Eddie. He certainly looks steady in these pictures, though considering his career perhaps they should have shown him with his glove on instead of holding a bat.

Ed Brinkman was a solid defender at shortstop, winning a Gold Glove in 1972 which somehow led to him being an American League All Star in 1973. Ed played all ten seasons that the second version of the Washington Senators existed from 1961 to 1970, then was traded to Detroit (along with third baseman Aurelio Rodriguez and pitcher Joe Coleman) for Denny McLain and Don Wert from the ’68 championship team. All three played a big part in the Tigers making it to the American League Championship Series in 1972. Eddie set an American League record in 1972 by playing in 72 straight errorless games (Mike Bordick of the Orioles most recently set the record at 110 games in 2002).

He was a high school teammate of Pete Rose at Western Hills High School in Cincinnati. Their coach said that Rose was a good player, “but no Brinkman.” After a stellar high school career, Eddie got the Senators to cough up a $75,000 bonus when he signed, which was a decent chunk of change for a ballplayer in 1961.

Rose, meanwhile, went largely unnoticed and ended up playing for an amateur league in Dayton, Ohio, after using up his high school eligibility. If his uncle hadn’t been a roving scout for the Reds, Rose might have never made it into professional baseball. The Reds gave him a miniscule payment to sign with them, and Ed later joked that Rose told him that “the Senators brought me my bonus in an armored truck. Pete said he had cashed his at the corner store.”

Ed was traded to the Cardinals as part of a three-way trade after the 1974 season in the deal that brought Padres’ slugger Nate Colbert to Detroit. He only played 24 games for St. Louis before they traded him to Texas – which is where the Washington franchise moved in 1971. He played just one game for the Rangers before the Yankees bought his contract in June of 1975. He’d had back problems for several years, and this limited him to just 44 games for the Bombers before he hung it up for good at the age of 33.

Ed played in an era where being a shortstop was primarily a defensive position; any hitting you got out of the position was a bonus. In 1,846 games, Ed hit .226 with 60 home runs, 461 RBI, and 30 stolen bases. He was later a minor league manager, coach, and scout for the Tigers and the White Sox before retiring from baseball in 2000.

His younger brother, Chuck, also played major league baseball as a catcher for the White Sox from 1969 to 1974, hitting .172 with one home run and 12 RBI in 149 games.

Ed Brinkman died in his hometown of Cincinnati on September 30, 2008, from heart disease. He was 66 years old.

Cardboard Tigers: The Managers

First in a series.

I just pulled out a bunch of my old baseball cards. I was fortunate enough to not have them thrown out by my mom in some year’s spring cleaning. So I have all of them and they’re in excellent shape considering almost all of them are over forty years old. And now you get to enjoy them, too, because an occasional blog post about them will be useful when I:

a) can’t think of anything else to write about, or

b) am too irritated to write about politics, or

c) all of the above.

(more…)